Smoke was about to come out of my ears. I ranted on Facebook and begged for some potty training advice. And I received a lot! Most of it we had already tried, candy, toy bribery, begging, etc.
The best advice, which I had already put into action before I read it, was to get rid of pull-ups and go hard-core underwear. It was scary and hadn't worked in the past, but I knew he was ready and was just being stubborn. We had a lot of accidents the first couple of days, including poop in the underwear. But he was so freaked every time it happened and worried that I would throw the underwear away, that it only happened 2-3 times and that was it. After about a week, we were mostly accident free. We also discovered Jonathan loves to pee standing up, "like Ann-roo" and on trees. I guess you have to be a boy to understand these little life treasures.
Now we just have to tackle night training. I'm not sure how to do it because Andrew basically trained himself in that area. Jonathan has enough issues sleeping through the night that I'm not sure I want to wake him anymore than he already does on his own. One step at a time! I am just thrilled to only have one in diapers!